+- Drunkard's Walk Forums (http://www.accessdenied-rms.net/forums)
+-- Forum: General (http://www.accessdenied-rms.net/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Politics and Other Fun (http://www.accessdenied-rms.net/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=17)
+--- Thread: Trump "exceeded his authority": federal judge (/showthread.php?tid=13023)
Trump "exceeded his authority": federal judge - robkelk - 08-26-2018
AP: Federal judge rules Trump "exceeded his authority" in issuing orders curtailing collective bargaining for federal workers
"This court finds that these provisions conflict with congressional intent in a manner that cannot be sustained"
Anybody want to bet that Trump learns from this that the US President is not an unlimited monarch? Anybody? Anybody?
RE: Trump "exceeded his authority": federal judge - classicdrogn - 08-26-2018
Feh. If only. More likely we see another round of "that ruling was a travesty."
RE: Trump "exceeded his authority": federal judge - Rajvik - 08-26-2018
Um, maybe someone should remind the judge of the precedent set against this by the air traffic controllers strike, because I'm sure it will be part of the brief when this is appealed
RE: Trump "exceeded his authority": federal judge - robkelk - 08-26-2018
Different circumstances - Reagan fired the ATCs, he didn't use an executive order to unilaterally change their contract.
RE: Trump "exceeded his authority": federal judge - Rajvik - 08-26-2018
(08-26-2018, 06:47 PM)robkelk Wrote: Different circumstances - Reagan fired the ATCs, he didn't use an executive order to unilaterally change their contract.
Reagan fired the ATC's because they tried to strike (aka use collective bargaining) would you rather Trump went there and told them they were all fired and that they could re-apply but that there would be no collective bargaining, or they keep their jobs and have to work out their own contracts from here on out?
RE: Trump "exceeded his authority": federal judge - robkelk - 08-26-2018
Yes, I would. Better that than change their contracts without their informed consent. However, if they're going to be let go, it had better be for cause. (Reagan had cause.)
Actually, I'm surprised that Trump pulled this stunt in the first place. If he'll change one contract, he'll change another - so who would risk entering into a contract with him knowing this once he's no longer President?
RE: Trump "exceeded his authority": federal judge - classicdrogn - 08-26-2018
If the numpty showed any ability to predict, or perhaps just the wit to care about, the consequences of his actions, that might be a factor. He's repeatedly demonstrated that he's exclusively about saying what sounds good (to and about himself at least) at the moment without any concern for the reactions it will cause, or even what he said in the last tweet/sound bite/etc..
RE: Trump "exceeded his authority": federal judge - Matrix Dragon - 08-27-2018
(08-26-2018, 09:10 PM)robkelk Wrote: who would risk entering into a contract with him knowing this once he's no longer President?
The same fucking morons he's been scamming for decades.