All The Tropes Wiki Project, Part XVII

[robkelk]

Could the other mods please review the recent changes to Tomboy and In Touch with His Feminine Side made by Raymanbell.  Not only is there a lot of it, some of it strikes me as subjective material presented as objective fact, they've added subvarieties of both that I've never seen categorized elsewhere, and (for the "Jaywalking" entry in this list) has apparently dug out and is using an extremely uncommon term, "Janegirl", for the male counterpart of a Tomboy as described in the second article, as though it were in daily usage.

EDIT:  I posted too soon:  They also spread their classification system to Tomboy and Girly Girl and Sensitive Guy and Manly Man

(goes and looks)

Trope redefinition without consensus. And Wikipedia redirects "Janegirl" to "sissy", so considering my current drive to get slurs out of the wiki that doesn't win any points in my book. And the blatant testosterone poisoning would only be (barely) tolerable if these were YMMV tropes, but they aren't.

Reverting the edits with this explanatory text as the edit reason:

(1) The edit substantially changed the definition of the trope without having gained consensus in the trope's Talk page or the wiki forum before being made, and (2) the edit contained an apparently-pejorative term that is not defined in the Merriam-Webster Dictionary or Oxford English Dictionary.

EDIT: And the way this troper redefined Sensitive Guy and Manly Man - by setting rules for what is or is not an example of the trope without gaining consensus for those rules beforeband - is clearly "trying to drown out others' opinions" and thus a violation of rule 1 of the Terms of Service. Raymanbell gets a three-day vacation from editing the wiki.