(04-07-2025, 09:29 AM)Bob Schroeck Wrote:(04-06-2025, 05:58 PM)GethN7 Wrote: Yes, the Complete Monster trope led to all sorts of edit wars and we even had a former admin meltdown and to be voted off the island over it. They still had idiot battles over this on Wikia and TV Tropes. Removing flashpoints of contention is a good thing.
I thought that we'd resolved to allow both existing and future entries on YMMV pages even though we'd removed examples from the trope page itself. Do I recall incorrectly?
From the outside looking in, it’s kind of vague.
The linked discussion topic on the Complete Monster page is something I (And presumably other users) don’t have permission to view. The page itself says no examples, which could be interpreted as local to that page or anywhere. The criteria page is still up without any prominent notes as to not creating new examples, though it could just be an oversight.