Thread Rating:
  • 1 Vote(s) - 3 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All The Tropes Wiki Project, Part XXXI
RE: All The Tropes Wiki Project, Part XXXI
My immediate reactions, as of less than a half-hour after waking up in the morning and seeing my computer wants to reboot:

(06-10-2025, 10:46 PM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: Pretty tired so I’m going to sit in responding to these till my social batteries are recharged, but I wanted to stash my notes on the oldest entries in the mod queue for tomorrow and get a second opinion before taking action on these

Notes on pending edits.
Pending edit for Bottle Episode
Section about the Twilight Zone is a match for the TVT Bottle Episode Subpage.
Content was added to TVT by user "6" on September 8th, 2024, predating its submission to ATT.

Reject and inform the troper why, pointing them at the appropriate copyright policy page.


(06-10-2025, 10:46 PM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: Pending edit for Galaxy Fraulein Yuna
Trope addition for No Fourth Wall looks quite similar to TVT, but the history doesn't go back far enough for me to tell who added it there.
The rest appears to be original.

Geth, could you check the history on this one, please? I seem to recall you have more access than the rest of us do.


(06-10-2025, 10:46 PM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: Pending edit for World of Action Girls
Entry for Arcana Heart is identical to the TVT equivalent. This was added by Laudy777 back in 2018.
The rest appears to be original.

Is the editor the same person as Laudy777?

Yes or no, the fact that it's been nearly a decade raises a red flag. Consider again when I'm awake...


(06-10-2025, 10:46 PM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: Pending edit for Variable Geo
Good edit except for the weird image rename that breaks the page image. Inclined to approve and manually revert the image.

Approve, repair, and tell the trope to not mangle file names.


(06-10-2025, 10:46 PM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: Pending edit for Potemayo/YMMV and Potemayo/Trivia
Content wise, this edit appears original. However it's mangled, and needs substantial copyediting.

Reject and tell the troper to try again. We're moderators, not editors.


(06-10-2025, 10:46 PM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: Pending edit for Adapted Out
Major revision to trope description, but not necessarily a bad one.

We asked for an edit pass on this page. If the description's meaning is the same and the grammar is better, let it through.


(06-10-2025, 10:46 PM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: Pending page creation for The Loud House'23
Formatting is borked. Regular use of all caps for emphasis. Redlink tropes galore.

Reject and tell the troper to read the Style Guide before trying again, using a new-page template.


(06-10-2025, 10:46 PM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: Pending edit for The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild/YMMV
Removal of subjective content. Even though this user created their account back in 2023, this appears to be their first edit. May have ignored the big yellow banner that comes up when editing that page. Note: This page is missing the standard YMMV header, the edit notice still appears.

Check the page history - if the page had the header before the edit, tell the troper to not remove essential page sections. Did they give in the edit summary a reason why they removed the content?
--
Rob Kelk

Sticks and stones can break your bones,
But words can break your heart.
- unknown

Boycotting all products from the USA as long as that country's leader continues to threaten to annex my native country.
Government of Canada: How to immigrate to Canada
Government of Canada: Claiming refugee protection (asylum) from within Canada


Messages In This Thread
RE: All The Tropes Wiki Project, Part XXXI - by robkelk - 06-11-2025, 05:46 AM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)