RE: All The Tropes Wiki Project, Part XXXII
08-10-2025, 10:32 AM (This post was last modified: 08-10-2025, 11:50 AM by MilkmanConspiracy.)
08-10-2025, 10:32 AM (This post was last modified: 08-10-2025, 11:50 AM by MilkmanConspiracy.)
Notes from review
Will have to leave a message telling them to read the style guide. As best I can tell, nothing seems to be plagiarized at least, but there’s a lot that’s questionable.
Significant notes:
* I would like to reject the edit to Bullying the Disabled/Web Original. Whilst it appears to be original content, it is for a trope page we don’t have.
* The edit to defector from Decadance probably goes too far. I don’t doubt there are bad editors on the sites they listed, as there are on most sites, but I think calling the whole site a wretched hive of GIFTs is a bit far.
Lower Priority:
* Would like a second opinion on their edit to Informed Wrongness.
* I would like a second opinion on No except Yes.
* I’m not sure how accurate the claim made in Unwitting Instigator of Doom is, but I stopped following My Little Pony news circa 2014.
* Speaking as one, Americans can indeed be culturally ignorant of the works in other countries as pointed out by the new edit in Adaptation Displacement. However I’m not sure how the Tick can be Adaptation Displacement for Supertorpe when Supertorpe came out after The Tick?
* On the fence about consolidation in Sadly Mythtaken, may warrant a partial revert.
* The page creation for Captain America Brave New World/YMMV is for one entry for a trope we don’t have, and a YMMV for a work we don’t have.
Will have to leave a message telling them to read the style guide. As best I can tell, nothing seems to be plagiarized at least, but there’s a lot that’s questionable.
Significant notes:
* I would like to reject the edit to Bullying the Disabled/Web Original. Whilst it appears to be original content, it is for a trope page we don’t have.
* The edit to defector from Decadance probably goes too far. I don’t doubt there are bad editors on the sites they listed, as there are on most sites, but I think calling the whole site a wretched hive of GIFTs is a bit far.
Lower Priority:
* Would like a second opinion on their edit to Informed Wrongness.
* I would like a second opinion on No except Yes.
* I’m not sure how accurate the claim made in Unwitting Instigator of Doom is, but I stopped following My Little Pony news circa 2014.
* Speaking as one, Americans can indeed be culturally ignorant of the works in other countries as pointed out by the new edit in Adaptation Displacement. However I’m not sure how the Tick can be Adaptation Displacement for Supertorpe when Supertorpe came out after The Tick?
* On the fence about consolidation in Sadly Mythtaken, may warrant a partial revert.
* The page creation for Captain America Brave New World/YMMV is for one entry for a trope we don’t have, and a YMMV for a work we don’t have.