(08-10-2025, 12:36 PM)robkelk Wrote:Thank you again for your help! I apologize for my accident.(08-10-2025, 10:32 AM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: Significant notes:
* I would like to reject the edit to Bullying the Disabled/Web Original. Whilst it appears to be original content, it is for a trope page we don’t have.
Which is sufficient grounds for rejection.
It also doesn't list a work name in its only example -- this makes me think that the text should have been added to the trope description, not marginalized in a subpage.
It's also the only subpage for the trope. It should have gone on the trope page.
The fact that the page is missing all of the automation that would have integrated it into the rest of the wiki (and thus made it possible to find the page) is just the cherry on top... even though we've rejected pages for that reason in the past.
(08-10-2025, 10:32 AM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: * The edit to defector from Decadance probably goes too far. I don’t doubt there are bad editors on the sites they listed, as there are on most sites, but I think calling the whole site a wretched hive of GIFTs is a bit far.
I'm not going to wait for consensus on that one. Edit undone to remove libellous text that put the entire wiki at legal risk. I've let them know that they are now On Notice.
(08-10-2025, 10:32 AM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: Lower Priority:
* Would like a second opinion on their edit to Informed Wrongness.
Complaining instead of fixing. I won't revert it, but I won't stop anyone else from reverting it, either.
(08-10-2025, 10:32 AM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: * I would like a second opinion on No except Yes.
I hung a {{context}} tag on the example that you didn't already fix.
(08-10-2025, 10:32 AM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: * I’m not sure how accurate the claim made in Unwitting Instigator of Doom is, but I stopped following My Little Pony news circa 2014.
Nor am I. But I've hung a {{verify}} tag on the Weasel Word.
(08-10-2025, 10:32 AM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: * Speaking as one, Americans can indeed be culturally ignorant of the works in other countries as pointed out by the new edit in Adaptation Displacement. However I’m not sure how the Tick can be Adaptation Displacement for Supertorpe when Supertorpe came out after The Tick?
The way I'm reading that one, they're saying Supertorpe displaced The Tick. I'd let that one go.
(08-10-2025, 10:32 AM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: * On the fence about consolidation in Sadly Mythtaken, may warrant a partial revert.
Partial revert done. That was a highly-detailed discussion of how "Ah! My Goddess" qualified that they replaced with a substantially shorter section shared with another work. With no edit reason given, there was no reason to cut the discussion.
(08-10-2025, 10:32 AM)MilkmanConspiracy Wrote: * The page creation for Captain America Brave New World/YMMV is for one entry for a trope we don’t have, and a YMMV for a work we don’t have.
"a YMMV for a work we don’t have" is sufficient reason to delete the page. They're welcome to create a work page, but not a subpage for a nonexistent page.
All The Tropes Wiki Project, Part XXXII
|
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)